One of the biggest challenges retirees face is ensuring their money lasts as long as they do. While Social Security provides a foundation of guaranteed income, it often falls short of covering all expenses. This is where annuities—insurance products that provide a stream of payments—come into play.
In recent years, annuities have attracted renewed attention, especially after the Secure Act and Secure 2.0 Act made it easier for employers to include annuities in retirement plans. With retirees living longer and market volatility threatening portfolios, annuities are being promoted as a way to create financial security.
But are they the right choice for everyone? Understanding the types of annuities, their advantages, drawbacks, and how they fit into retirement planning is crucial before making a decision.
Table of Contents
What Is an Annuity?
An annuity is a contract between an individual and an insurance company. In exchange for a lump sum or a series of payments, the insurer guarantees regular income for a set period—or even for life.
Main Types of Annuities
- Immediate Annuity: Starts paying income almost right away, usually within a year of purchase.
- Deferred Annuity: Payments begin at a future date, allowing the investment to grow tax-deferred until then.
- Fixed Annuity: Provides guaranteed, predictable payments.
- Variable Annuity: Payments fluctuate based on the performance of underlying investments.
- Indexed Annuity: Payments tied to the performance of a market index, with both risk and protection limits.
Annuities and Secure 2.0
The Secure 2.0 Act introduced reforms that strengthen the role of annuities in retirement planning:
- Lifetime Income Options in 401(k)s: Employers can now more easily offer annuities in workplace retirement plans.
- Portability Rules: Workers can move annuity contracts from one retirement plan to another without surrender charges or penalties.
- Relaxed RMD Rules: Certain annuities have more flexibility in calculating required minimum distributions, allowing smoother income planning.
These reforms aim to make annuities more accessible and encourage retirees to use them as a way to secure predictable income.
Pros of Annuities for Retirees
1. Guaranteed Lifetime Income
- Annuities can provide income for life, helping retirees avoid the risk of outliving their savings.
- This makes them especially appealing to those without traditional pensions.
2. Protection Against Market Volatility
- Fixed and immediate annuities are not affected by stock market swings, offering stability in uncertain times.
3. Tax Deferral on Growth
- Earnings within an annuity grow tax-deferred until withdrawals begin.
- This can be an advantage for retirees who want to delay taxation.
4. Customization Options
- Annuities can be tailored with riders for inflation protection, long-term care coverage, or spousal continuation.
Cons of Annuities for Retirees
1. Complexity
- Many retirees find annuities difficult to understand. Fees, riders, and surrender schedules can make contracts confusing.
2. High Costs
- Commissions and administrative fees may erode returns, particularly in variable and indexed annuities.
3. Illiquidity
- Annuities often tie up funds for long periods. Early withdrawals can trigger steep penalties and tax consequences.
4. Inflation Risk
- Fixed annuities may lose purchasing power over time unless adjusted with cost-of-living increases.
Cost Comparison Example
Consider a retiree with $200,000:
- Immediate Fixed Annuity (age 65): Could provide about $1,000–$1,200 per month for life, depending on insurer rates.
- Variable Annuity: Payments may start lower but can increase if underlying investments perform well.
- Without Annuity (investing in bonds and stocks): Income would vary depending on market performance, with no guarantee of lasting for life.
This comparison shows why annuities appeal to those prioritizing security over growth.
Who Should Consider Annuities?
- Retirees without pensions who want another source of guaranteed income alongside Social Security.
- Individuals worried about longevity risk (living longer than expected).
- Those uncomfortable with market risk and looking for predictable payments.
- Retirees in good health, since annuities benefit those who live longer.
Who May Not Benefit from Annuities?
- Retirees with strong pensions or high Social Security benefits may not need them.
- Those with limited savings, since tying up money in annuities can reduce liquidity for emergencies.
- Individuals who prefer flexibility and direct control of investments.
The Role of Annuities in a Retirement Plan
Financial experts often recommend using annuities to cover basic living expenses, while relying on investment accounts for discretionary spending and growth.
For example:
- Essential Expenses (housing, food, healthcare): Covered by Social Security + annuity payments.
- Non-Essential Expenses (travel, hobbies, legacy): Funded by retirement savings, IRAs, and other investments.
This approach balances security with flexibility.
Annuities are neither perfect nor universally necessary, but they can play a valuable role in retirement planning. The Secure 2.0 Act has made them more accessible by integrating them into workplace retirement plans and offering new flexibility.
For retirees concerned about running out of money, annuities provide peace of mind through guaranteed income. Yet they come with trade-offs—fees, complexity, and inflation risks—that must be carefully weighed.
The decision to buy an annuity should be based on personal circumstances, including health, risk tolerance, other income sources, and long-term goals. For some retirees, they are a cornerstone of financial stability; for others, they may be unnecessary.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Q1. Are annuity payments guaranteed for life?
Yes, many annuities provide lifetime payments, though terms vary by contract. Some offer payments for a fixed period instead.
Q2. Can I lose money in an annuity?
Yes. Variable and indexed annuities carry investment risks, while fixed annuities guarantee payments but may lose value to inflation.
Q3. Are annuities a good substitute for pensions?
They can act as a “personal pension,” providing stable income when traditional pensions are unavailable.
Q4. Do annuities count toward RMDs?
Yes, annuities held in tax-deferred accounts like IRAs are subject to RMDs, though Secure 2.0 provided more flexible rules for certain contracts.
Q5. When is the best time to buy an annuity?
Typically between ages 60 and 70, when retirees are preparing to transition from savings to income.